Key West Rum Barrel Bar & Grill
  • About Us
  • Menu
    Key West
    Restaurant Menu
    Key West Bar Menu Key West Happy Hour Order Online
  • Events
  • Weddings & Private Parties
  • Contact Us
Flatbread pizza Appetizers Leaves & Bowls Buns big plates dessert kids menu bar menu happy hour order online
Michael Schultz
Michael Schultz’s career started at age 14, cooking at The Lobster House in Cape May, New Jersey, where he found a love for the culinary arts.

HAPPY HOUR

2-for-1 Drinks

4PM – 7PM
Includes:
All Well Drinks, Domestic Bottles and Non-Kraft Drafts

2 for 1!
Photo of Philly Cheese Steak Rolls

Baked Potato Philly Style
Topped with a Philly Cheese Steak WIT WHIZ

Cannon Fries
With bacon, cheese, pico de gallo & sour cream

Cheese Steak Egg Rolls (2)
Flash fried & served with white cheese sauce

Chicken Wings (5)
Choice of Jamaican Jerk, Hot, Mild, BBQ

Chicken Tenders (3)
Choice of Jamaican Jerk, Hot, Mild, BBQ

Soft Pretzel Bites
With Inner Beauty mustard sauce & jerked salt

Caesar Salad
Topped with (2) flash fried chicken tenders

$5 Appetizer Menu!

Flatbread Pizza's

Photo of Margherita Flatbread
Margherita

Vine ripe tomatoes, imported buffalo mozzarella, sweet basil plain and simple, baked to perfection. $10

Photo of The Scampi Flatbread
The Scampi

Sauteed shrimp, roasted garlic, oven dried tomatoes, shaved parmesan and lemon confit. $12

Photo of The Cypress Flatbread
The Cypress

Grilled artichoke, Mediterranean olives, feta, garden basil, mint and Greek extra virgin olive oil. $10

appetizers

conch-fritters
Queen Conch Fritters

A Bahamian treat, with key lime cocktail sauce. $11

Photo of Philly Cheesesteak Spring Rolls
Philly Cheese Steak Spring Rolls

2 jumbo spring rolls filled with tender grilled ribeye and sautéed onions with a creamy white cheddar sauce and roasted pepper salad. $8

chicken-wings
Chicken Wings

With house made ranch or blue cheese and celery sticks. Bakers dozen. $14
Choose your style:
Sunday Drive
I’m Late for Work
The Baby’s Coming!
Gluten Free

Photo of Snacks
Snack Pack

A sampling of house made munchies. $12

Photo of Soft Pretzel Bites
Soft Pretzel Bites

Jamaican jerk and herb butter soft pretzel bites served with habenero honey-mustard. $7

nachos
Deep Dish Nachos

With frijoles, roasted tomato salsa, guacamole, queso fresco, fresh jalapenos, sour cream and warm tortilla chips on the side. $11
Add chipotle spiced ground beef: $2

Photo of Peel and eat shrimp
Peel and Eat Key West Pinks

Down and dirty with cocktail sauce, lime and plenty of napkins ½ lb or 1 lb. m.p
Gluten Free

Photo of Chicken Tenders
Chicken Tenders

5 crispy chicken tenders lightly fried and tossed in your choice of jerk, bbq, hot or mild sauce.
House ranch or blue cheese. $10

Photo of Crab Cake
Mick’s Signature Blue Crabcake

Panko dusted and fried with a Thai cucumber noodle salad and sriracha aioli. $11

Photo of Diver Scallops
Seared Diver Scallops

With yo mamas grits, cilantro and a lime brown butter sauce. $13
Gluten Free

Photo Island Curry Grilled Shrimp
Island Curry Grilled Shrimp

Over a coconut couscous salad and warm toasted almond oil. $11

Photo of Loaded Cannon Fries
Loaded Cannon Fries

A Rum Barrel classic, crispy golden french fries loaded up with house bacon, melted cheese, pico de gallo, fresh jalapenos and sour cream. $9
Gluten Free

Photo of Spicy Sparagus
Spicy ’Sparagus

Tender spears of asparagus sautéed with caramelized peppers & onions, tossed with bacon in a spicy Szechuan stir-fry sauce. $9.95

Leaves & Bowls

Photo of Croce Salad
The Croce Salad

PC’s Signature Salad. Baby greens, crumbled bleu cheese, carrots, tomatoes, hard-boiled egg, bacon, red grapes, dried cranberries, scallions and pistachios. $12.95
Gluten Free

Photo of House Salad
Rum Barrel House Salad

With mixed field greens, cherry tomatoes and crisp cucumbers. $8
Dressings: Balsamic, Ranch, Caesar, Florida Citrus
Gluten Free

Photo of Classic Caesar Salad
Classic Caesar

With shaved parmesan and soft pretzel croutons. $9
Add grilled shrimp or chicken. $5

Photo of the wedge salad
The Wedge

Crisp iceberg lettuce with house made bacon, cherry tomatoes, red onions and maytag blue cheese dressing. $9

Photo of French Onion Soup
French Onion Soup

Day old crouton and swiss cheese. $7

Photo of Red Conch Chowder
Key West Red Conch Chowder

Tender Bahamian queen conch, potatoes, bacon, celery and a blend of island spices. $8
Gluten Free

Buns

Served with fries or a side salad.

Photo of Maine Lobster Roll
Maine Lobster Roll Island Style

Tender chunks of New England lobster mixed with spices, mayo and Caribbean fruits served on a toasted roll. $17

Photo of Chicken Philly
Chicken Cheese Steak

“BEST OF PHILLY WINNER”! Tender chicken breast sauteed with garlic, shallots, fresh thyme, roasted portobello mushrooms, shredded parmesan and provolone on a toasted roll. $12

Photo of Philly Cheese Steak
Classic Philly Cheese Steak

Aged ribeye grilled with sweet onions served on an Amoroso roll “wit” your choice
of provolone, American or whiz. $11

Photo of Big Ass Burger
Big Ass Burger

Key West’s biggest burger! A fire grilled ten ounce burger with lettuce, tomato, red onion and dill pickle with
your choice of cheese on a toasted bistro bun. American, swiss, cheddar or provolone. $14
Add house made bacon $1.75

kobe-beef-hotdog
1/4 lb. Kobe Beef Hot Dog

House made kraut, grain mustard and diced dill pickles on a toasted New England bun. $11

Photo of The Reef Burger
The “Reef” Burger

8 oz fire grilled Buckhead beef patty topped with shrimp salad, melted cheddar, vine ripe tomato on a toasted bun with old bay fries. $14

Photo of The Original Burger
Barrel Burger

8 oz fire grilled Buckhead beef patty, southern butter, vine ripe tomato, sliced red onion and crisp lettuce on a toasted bun with choice of American, cheddar or provolone. $11

Photo of Blackened Snapper Reuben
Blackened Yellow Tail Snapper Reuben

House Thousand Island, kraut, swiss and toasted rye bread. M.P.

Photo of Grilled Chicken BLT
Grilled chicken “blt”

fire grilled chicken breast topped with house bacon, lettuce, vine ripe tomato and mayo
on a toasted bistro bun. $12

Photo of Tuna Avocado Melt
Tuna Avocado Melt Sandwich

Grilled or Blackened Ahi Tuna with Key Lime Aioli, Avocado, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion and Melted Swiss on a Kaiser Roll. Served with Crinkle Cut Fries. $12.5

Photo of Crispy Apple Sliders
House Made Crispy Scrapple Sliders

Served open face over a savory french toast with shaved apples and Lancaster honey. $10

Photo of Slider of the Day
SLIDER of the day

Chef’s daily preparation. P.A.

BIG PLATES

Photo of Steak Frites
Steak Frites

A classic pub offering, fire grilled 10 oz NY strip steak with green pepper corn butter, a pub salad and fries. $27
Gluten Free

Photo of Mahi Mahi
Joe’s Tug Mahi Mahi

Over a spiced sweet potato puree with a shaved fennel salad and a Florida citrus vinaigrette. $19
Gluten Free

Photo of Lobster Mac and Cheese
Lobster Mac and Cheese

Sweet maine lobster with elbow macaroni and a creamy cheddar cheese sauce topped with toasted bread crumbs.
Half portion $11
Full portion $21

photo of etouffee
New Orleans chicken etouffee pasta

Sautéed chicken breast with andouille sausage, crawfish and a classic creole etouffee served over penne pasta with grilled sourdough bread. $21

Dessert

Photo of Key Lime Pie
Key West Key Lime Pie

The Best We’ve Found. Perfectly Prepared with Real Key Lime Custard, Meringue, and a Graham Cracker Crust. $5.95

Photo of Cinnamon Bun Bread Pudding
Cinnamon Bun Bread Pudding

Sinfully Good and Drizzled with The Barrel’s Rum Sauce. $6.95

Photo of Chocolate Cake
Overboard Chocolate Cake

Three Layers of Chocolate Cake Filled with Crunchy Malted Milk Ball Mousse. Topped with Gobs of Cake and Fudge. Served with a Steak Knife. $8.95

Photo of Colossal Cheesecake
Colossal N.Y. Cheesecake

Creamy and Decadent with a Graham Cracker Crust and Drizzled with Strawberry Coulis. $6.95

KIDS MENU

Includes beverage and is served with fries or apple sauce. $8.95

Chicken Fingers

Includes beverage and is served with fries or apple sauce. $8.95

Fish Fingers

Includes beverage and is served with fries or apple sauce. $8.95

Cheeseburger

Includes beverage and is served with fries or apple sauce. $8.95

Grilled Cheese

Made with fresh tomato and cheese. $8.95

Cheese Pizza

BAR MENU

Photo of Signature Rum

We have sailed the world to compile the most comprehensive rum selection and are proud to present the finest rums in the world. Whether an aficionado or a novice, we believe you’ll enjoy tasting the libation that embodies the history, character and spirit of the Caribbean. Click Here to download The Rum Bible.
Pyrat XO Reserve (Anguilla)
Select blend of fine, 15-year old Caribbean rums. Smooth finish and delicious notes of toffee and vanilla.
Pyrat Cask 23 (Anguilla)
One of the finest rums in the world. A blend of rums aged up to 40 years. The initial smell is sweet with hints of orange and delicately charred oak. It has tones of molasses, fruitiness, and a touch of honey.

Select Aged Rums
Photo of Signature Rum Drinks

We have sailed the world to compile the most comprehensive rum selection and are proud to present the finest rums in the world. Whether an aficionado or a novice, we believe you’ll enjoy tasting the libation that embodies the history, character and spirit of the Caribbean. Click Here to download The Rum Bible.
Marooned
If stranded on a desert island by your crew, don’t be left high and dry without one of these. Malibu Coco, Cruzan Vanilla, Crème de Coconut, pineapple and OJ, Cruzan Black Strap floater.
The 302
Two shots of Bacardi 151 blended smoothly into your choice of banana, mango, pina colada, raspberry, rum runner, or strawberry slushy. This drink should be outlawed in most states. God bless the Conch Republic.
Rum Barrel
Bacardi Select, Bacardi Gold, Bacardi 151 with cranberry, pineapple and orange juices, splash of grenadine. Peg leg included, B.Y.O. parrot.
Kill Devil
A “fiery” concoction sure to please two or more pirates. Mango and coconut flavored rums, Southern Comfort, Amaretto, Sloe Gin, orange and pineapple juices, and grenadine. We omitted Blackbeard’s traditional gunpowder ingredient and added a flaming 151-soaked orange slice on top! Served in a souvenir Rum Barrel bucket!

Signature Rum Barrel Drinks
Photo of a Mojito

Island Barrel
The Barrel’s signature libation shaken as a fruity version with Malibu Coconut, Malibu Pineapple and Malibu Mango with cranberry, pineapple and orange juices and a splash of grenadine.
Redbeard’s Bloody
The bloodiest of bloody marys…can be served with Absolut or Absolut Peppar. Seasoned salt rim and garnished with a pickle.
Groovy Margarita
Only the top shelf for Groovy. Conmemorativo Tequila, Cointreau, and fresh lime juice – on the rocks with a kosher salt rim.
The John Daly
Sweet Tea Vodka and Lemonade with a lemon. Very refreshing!

Island Favorites

Mojitos
A Mojito is a chillingly refreshing, effervescent fusion of rum and muddled fresh lime, mint and sugar, topped with club soda. The Barrel’s Mo- jito menu is proudly hand-crafted by our expertly trained bar staff with the finest ingredients. This fashionable Cuban cocktail is rapidly gaining popularity as the next hot drink.

Original Mojito
Dates back to the 1800s. Bacardi Light with muddled lime, fresh mint and sugar, shaken and topped with a splash of soda.

Flavored Mojito
Your Choice of: Malibu Mango, Malibu Passion Fruit Seagram’s Raspberry Rum Bacardi Peach

Caipirinhas
Brazil’s most revered libation, the Caipirinha (KY-pa-REEN-yah), is a invigorating combination of cachaca and freshly muddled lime and sugar. Cachaca (kuh-SHA-suh), often referred to as Brazilian rum, is the national spirit of Brazil and made from sugar cane as opposed to molasses.

Leblon Caipirinha
Sip on this heavenly cocktail and be transported to Leblon, the hip beach neighborhood outside of Rio de Janeiro. Premium Leblon cachaca with muddled lime and sugar over rocks.

Muddled Favorites

Mermaid Cosmo
Absolut Mandarin, triple sec, fresh lime and white cranberry juices.
Key Lime Pie Martini
Dessert with benefits! The Barrel’s secret recipe blends the perfect balance of sweet, tart, and strong. Rimmed with graham cracker.
Shark Bite Cosmo
Absolut Citron, Blue Curacao and white cranber- ry juice with a splash of grenadine and a cherry.

Specialty Martinis

Frogman Ale
Guinness
Miller Lite
Magic Hat #9
Yuengling
Framboise Lambic
Shock-Top Belgian White
Widmer
Mile Marker Zero
Blue Point Toasted Lager
Wood Chuck Hard Cider Pear
Stella Artois
Bud Light
Dogfish Head 60 Minute
Dogfish Head 90 Minute IPA
Samuel Adams Seasonal
Magic Hat Seasonal
Beer of the Month

Draft Mixes
Dirty Hoe (Shock Top & Framboise Lambic)
Black & Tan (Guinness & Yuengling)
Red Velvet (Guinness & Framboise Lambic)
Black Pear (Guinness & Wood Chuck Cider Pear)
Black Magic (Guinness & Magic Hat #9)

Draught Beer

Domestic
Budweiser
Bud Light
Bud Light Lime
Coors Light
Michelob Ultra
Miller Lite
Sam Adams Boston Lager
Yuengling Lager
Yuengling Light
Key West Sunset Ale
Land Shark Lager
Twister Tea Original

Import
Amstel Light
Red Stripe
Corona
Corona Light
St. Pauli Girl (non-alcoholic)
Strongbow (16oz)
Dos Equis Lager
Heineken
Heineken Light

Bottled Beer

Whites
Barefoot Chardonnay
Four Vines Naked Chardonnay
William Hill Chardonnay
Barefoot White Zinfindale
Barefoot Pinot Grigio
Robert Pepi Pinot Grigio
Santa Ema Sauvignon Blanc

Reds
Barefoot Merlot
Lucky Star Pinot Noir
Artezin Red Zinfindale
Kaiken Malbec
Barefoot Cabernet Sauvignon
Sean Minor 4 Bears Cabernet Sauvignon
Louis Martini Cabernet Sauvignon

Wine List

LaMarca Prosecco
Korbel Champagne
Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label Champagne
Freixenet Champagne (Split)
Zonin Prosecco (Split)

Bubbly

HAPPY HOUR

2-for-1 Drinks

4PM – 7PM
Includes:
All Well Drinks, Domestic Bottles and Non-Kraft Drafts

2 for 1!
Photo of Philly Cheese Steak Rolls

Baked Potato Philly Style
Topped with a Philly Cheese Steak WIT WHIZ

Cannon Fries
With bacon, cheese, pico de gallo & sour cream

Cheese Steak Egg Rolls (2)
Flash fried & served with white cheese sauce

Chicken Wings (5)
Choice of Jamaican Jerk, Hot, Mild, BBQ

Chicken Tenders (3)
Choice of Jamaican Jerk, Hot, Mild, BBQ

Soft Pretzel Bites
With Inner Beauty mustard sauce & jerked salt

Caesar Salad
Topped with (2) flash fried chicken tenders

$5 Appetizer Menu!
305-292-7862
528 Front Street
Key West, FL 33040
Hours of Operation:
Open: 11:00am to CLOSE
7 DAYS A WEEK

About Us

Key West Restaurant
Pat Croce
Director Michael Schultz
Executive Chef Mick Pera
Rum Barrel Blog

Our Menu

Download the Rum Bible!
Restaurant Menu
Key West Happy Hour
Key West Bar Menu
Order Online
Appetizers

Soups & Salads
Sandwiches
Best Burgers in Key West
Key West Seafood
Off The Grill
Dessert

Events and Venues

Key West Live Music
Key West Wedding Receptions
Private Parties in Key West
Event Request Form

Copyright © 2006/2019 RUM BARREL INC.